January 20, 2022
Garner Insurance Agency, LLC.

Claims Reporting

To better assist you, the following carriers have 24 hour direct claim reporting services available. Prior to calling, please have your policy number and claim details available for the claims adjuster. The insurance carrier will forward a copy of your claim report to our office. Also, if we can assist you in any way, please do not hesitate to contact us.


American Modern Insurance Group

For After Hours Claims Reporting On American Modern Policies.

File An American Modern Claim

1 (800) 375-2075

Auto Owners Insurance

For After Hours Claims Reporting On Auto-Owners Policies.

File An Auto-Owners Claim

1 (888) 252-4626

Chubb Group of Insurance Companies

For After Hours Claims Reporting On Chubb Group Policies.

File A Chubb Group Claim

1 (800) 252-4670

GuideOne Insurance

For After Hours Claims Reporting On GuideOne Policies.

File a GuideOne Claim

1 (888) 748-4326

Hartford Insurance Company

For After Hours Claims Reporting On The Hartford Policies.

File A Hartford Claim

1 (800) 243-5860 for Personal Auto & Homeowners

1 (800) 327-3636 for Commercial Insurance Policies

Insurance Board

For After Hours Claims Reporting On Insurance Board Policies.

File An Insurance Board Claim

1 (800) 716-3196

KEMI - Kentucky Employers Mutual Insurance

For After Hours Claims Reporting On KEMI Policies.

File A KEMI Claim

1 (800) 640-5364

KESA - Kentucky Employers Safety Association

For After Hours Claims Reporting On KESA Policies.

File A KESA Claim

1 (800) 367-5372

KY AGC Self Insurers' Fund

For After Hours Claims Reporting On KY AGC SIF Policies.

File A KY AGC SIF Claim

1 (502) 245-2007

MetLife Auto & Home

For After Hours Claims Reporting on MetLife Auto & Home Policies.

File A MetLife Auto & Home Claim

1 (800) 854-6011

Motorists Mutual Group

For After Hours Claims Reporting on Motorists Mutual Policies.

File A Motorists Mutual Claim

1 (800) 876-8766

Progressive

For After Hours Claims Reporting On Progressive Policies.

File A Progressive Claim

1 (800) PROGRESSIVE

Safeco Insurance Company

For After Hours Claims Reporting On Safeco Policies.

File A Safeco Claim

1( 800) 332-3226

Travelers Insurance Group

For After Hours Claims Reporting On Travelers Policies.

File A Travelers Claim

1 (800) 252-4633 for Personal Auto or Homeowners

1 (800) 238-6225 for Commercial Policies

Western Reserve Group

For After Hours Claims Reporting on Wetsern Reserve Policies.

File A Western Reserve Claim

1 (800) 362-0426